The Cable Gamer doesn't exactly know what to make of The Huffington Post these days. The politics of Huffpo are overwhelmingly liberal, but the site's media criticism is quite often insightful, and always seems to be bolstered by facts and hyperlinks. And that makes Huffpo a must-read for Cable Gamers.
A case in point is Danny Shea, who noted earlier this week that CNN prexy Jon Klein mostly gets an admiring press--which he doesn't quite deserve. In Shea's words:
While TVNewser recently threw Klein's words back at him at once comparing his 2007 declaration that CNN is a "real news network" and his 2008 announcement of a D.L. Hughley comedy news show Klein often goes unchallenged by the media press. Just last week, for instance, the New York Observer ran a story about CNN's spending spree quoting Klein as saying, "We can afford more people on our air and off our air. So, goddamn it, we're going to have more people" without mentioning, say, that the network came under fire over the summer for trying to spin layoffs in the Chicago bureau as a nationwide expansion.
Piling up prodigious research, Shea revealed some interesting gaps between the CNN chief's promise and performance. Here, for example, is some of what Shea found--he invited readers to join him on "A trip down Jon Klein's Predictions That Didn't Pan Out memory lane":
Aaron Brown: The Washington Post wrote in 2005, "One month after announcing that Anderson Cooper and Aaron Brown would continue to be the 'fire and ice' of CNN's 'NewsNight,' CNN/US President Jon Klein said ice is toast." Indeed, Klein assured the Philadelphia Inquirer in October 2006, "There's no plan to slowly phase out Aaron...he's doing a really good job" only to fire Brown one month later.
"American Morning"/Miles O'Brien: In June 2005, a Dallas Morning News article on CNN's hard news focus described the pitch for a retooled "American Morning" featuring Miles O'Brien and Soledad O'Brien: "In a morning television landscape littered with mindless entertainment, there will be one name you can rely on for no-nonsense news: O'Brien." Miles O'Brien was replaced by the network in 2007. Klein also told the Los Angeles Times in 2007 that "American Morning can really catch on with viewers." Of course, the show recently lost a weekly ratings race to MSNBC's "Morning Joe" for the first time, and "Fox & Friends" beats both shows by significant margins.
And, amazingly, considering the politics of Huffpo, Shea added this mockery of CNN's designs against Fox:
The Fight Against Fox News: In that same 2005 Dallas Morning News article, Klein said Fox News "should be [nervous]. Because we haven't even started trying yet." In 2006, in response to a question about why CNN still trails Fox News, Klein said, "I don't know, but we're going to change that." As recently as this month, the New York Times wrote that "Jonathan Klein, the president of CNN/U.S., predicted that his channel's approach -- news without an overt ideological spin -- would prevail in the long term."
The only problem, of course, is that CNN still reliably trails Fox News on a day-to-day basis. In fact, according to Nielsen ratings, CNN has lost 4% of market share over the past four years (Klein's tenure) while Fox News has gained 5%. CNN may win the big nights Election Night, for instance, which it won by over 3 million viewers) but it doesn't retain them, according to an article this weekend in Broadcasting & Cable. Even Larry King has become vulnerable to a surging MSNBC (in the form of Rachel Maddow), and on a nightly basis, the race is more between MSNBC and CNN for 2nd place than between CNN and Fox News for first.
And then Shea concludes:
Jon Klein may be "happily irrepressible," as Jon Friedman put it in his 2006 profile, and so it's unlikely as he moves into his next four years running CNN that he'll monitor his words any more closely. But given the track record of how his bold statements and predictions have panned out, the media press will need to do a better job of that for him.
So this rigor aimed at CNN? The Cable Gamer can think of two possible explanations:
First, Huffpo is carrying MSNBC's water, big time, trying to knock the center-left network, CNN, off stride in its battle with the hard-left MSNBC.
Second, Arianna's site--once dismissed as limousine-liberal vanity project--is now emerging as a serious journalistic player.
To be continued.
